Here’s how the story goes: Matthew Shinnick was trying to sell a pair of mountain bikes on Craigslist. He found a buyer and they agreed on a price of $600. The buyer mailed him a check for $2,000. Instead of depositing the check at his bank, he went to a Bank of America branch, where he was not a customer. He asked the teller to check if the account had sufficient funds to cover the check, the account did, but the check was phony. The teller let the branch manager handle the situation, and he called the police and reported suspicious activity. The police came and arrested Shinnick and he spent around 12 hours in jail. (Full Story)
Okay, when I first heard about the whole thing, I just said, oh great, another fool and his money are parted. What’s different about it this time? I found out Clark Howard from The Clark Howard Show is “taking on Bank of America” in asking them to close accounts or withdraw money. How idiotic is this?
One, we can safely assume Clark Howard doesn’t give a damn about Matthew Shinnick, this is just great publicity for him.
Two, Matthew Shinnick is an idiot. I can’t see how people can have sympathy for him. Scammers prey on weak minded people like Shinnick who can’t smell a simple scam. Never try to cash checks you think might be phony. Never accept checks for online sales at Craiglists, eBay, etc. etc. Especially checks that are more than 2 times what you originally agreed upon. Also a check from a buyer that lives in another country.
Three, Bank of America shouldn’t reimburse Shinnick for his troubles, they were not at fault, all they did was report suspicious activity to law enforcement. It is up to the SFPD to use discretion in handling of the matter. The reasoning is to try go after Bank of America because they have deep pockets, as compared to the SFPD.